Is it a regulated broker? How to tell which licence actually protects you

A broker’s brand can cover several legal entities. Check which company holds your account, its regulator and the protections that apply.

Open the same online trading website from Montreal, Melbourne and Johannesburg and you may find three different companies named in the fine print. Many international brokers run a family of separate companies, each licensed by a different regulator. The one you sign up with decides your leverage limits, your complaint options and how much protection you get if something goes wrong.

So calling a firm a regulated broker only tells you half the story. The real question is "which company am I opening an account with, and who regulates that company?"

Why one brand can have several licences

Financial regulation is national, and in Canada it is also provincial. A broker that wants clients in several countries usually sets up a local company in each market and applies for a licence there. A few patterns are worth knowing:

The brand name on the website is often a trading name. The legal entity is listed in small print, usually in the footer or the client agreement.

Your country of residence normally decides which entity you are assigned to, sometimes only once you reach the sign-up form.

Some groups also run entities in offshore centres such as the Seychelles or the British Virgin Islands, where the rules on leverage and client protection are generally looser.

The protections belong to the entity, not to the brand. A strong licence held by one company in the group does nothing for a client whose account sits with another.

What changes from one regulator to the next

Leverage is the clearest example. It lets you control a large position with a small deposit, which magnifies both gains and losses. Australia's regulator, ASIC, caps retail leverage on major currency pairs at 30:1. Some offshore-licensed entities advertise leverage in the hundreds or even thousands to one, which means a tiny price move can wipe out an account.

Other differences matter just as much. Some regulators require negative balance protection, which stops a retail client losing more than the money in the account. Some give clients access to an independent complaints service or a compensation scheme. Others offer little beyond a registration number.

None of this makes trading safer or riskier on its own. Contracts for difference (CFDs) and leveraged forex carry a high risk of fast losses everywhere. What regulation changes is how fairly you are treated and what help you have if a dispute arises.

How Montreal investors can check a firm

In Quebec, the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) oversees firms that sell investments or offer derivatives such as CFDs and forex. The AMF's five steps to avoid fraud put verifying authorization first. You can search the AMF's register of authorized firms and individuals or call its information centre toll-free at 1 877 525-0337.

Across Canada, the Canadian Securities Administrators run a free National Registration Search at aretheyregistered.ca, which the AMF has encouraged investors to use before handing over money. The AMF also publishes investor warnings, and its list regularly includes CFD and forex sites that solicit Quebecers without authorization.

If a firm you're considering doesn't appear on either register, a licence elsewhere in the world doesn't change that. You would be dealing with it outside the protection of Quebec's rules.

Checking a regulated broker in South Africa and elsewhere

Readers with family abroad, or who split their time between countries, may come across brokers licensed elsewhere. Every serious regulator publishes a way to check its licence holders.

In South Africa, the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) authorises financial services providers and gives each one an FSP number. A regulated broker SA residents can use should be able to give you that number, and you can confirm it on the FSCA's online FSP search. Check that the company name on the register matches the company on your account application.

The table shows what to look for in a few common jurisdictions:

Where

Regulator

What to check

Quebec

AMF

The AMF register of authorized firms and individuals

Canada (all provinces)

Canadian Securities Administrators

The National Registration Search

Australia

ASIC

An Australian financial services licence on ASIC's Professional Registers Search

South Africa

FSCA

An FSP number on the FSCA's provider search

Offshore centres such as the Seychelles

Local financial services authority

The licence number, and whether any compensation scheme or complaints service applies

Frequently asked questions

How do I find out which company I'm signing up with?

Read the footer of the website, the client agreement and the account application. If the sign-up form names a different company from the one on the home page, ask the broker why before you deposit anything.

Does a licence mean my money is safe?

No. A licence means the company is supervised and must follow certain rules. It doesn't protect you from market losses, and CFDs and leveraged forex carry a high risk of losing money quickly.

Is higher leverage a good thing?

It's a bigger risk, not a bonus. Higher leverage means a smaller price move can close your position and wipe out your deposit.

Can I complain to the AMF about a foreign broker?

You can report a firm that solicits Quebecers without authorization, and the AMF does publish warnings about such firms. Getting money back from an unregistered overseas firm is much harder than resolving a dispute with a registered one.

The bottom line

Calling itself a regulated broker tells you very little about the protection you'll get. Find the legal entity on your account, look up its regulator, and check the licence on that regulator's own register. For Montreal investors, the AMF register and the National Registration Search are the place to start, wherever the broker says it is based.