This column reflects the views of its author.
Elbows up for whom?
Nathan Colquhoun looks at what Ottawa gave up on the Gordie Howe bridge and asks who has benefited from Mark Carney’s version of “elbows up.”

Wayne Gretzky thought Gordie Howe was the greatest player who ever lived. He also remembered taking the puck off Howe and getting a stick across the hand for it. Phil Esposito found out about the elbows in his second NHL game. You could come away from an encounter with Gordie Howe with a fairly complete education in what belonged to whom.
Howe was a right winger. He scored 801 NHL goals, and Scotty Bowman remembered him as a complete player. There’s a bit of hockey strategy in that which gets lost when the story is mostly about somebody taking an elbow in the teeth. In the corner, you put your body between the puck and the other player. If you can hold it there for another second, a teammate has time to get open. Now you can get the puck out of the corner on your terms. Howe was famously hard to move off the puck, and he could do something with it once he had the room. The elbow made sense because of what came next.
The phrase was in print as hockey language by 1972, and by 1985 a Toronto newspaper was using it for a fight over political delegates. Then an American president started talking about turning Canada into a state, and a Canadian comedian went on American television wearing a shirt that said Canada was not for sale. It was a ridiculous way to have to make the point. Of course it worked. People rallied on Parliament Hill, left American booze on the shelf and cancelled trips across the border. The Liberals eventually got Carney and Myers together at a rink. There they were, elbows up, and the rest of us could do our part by finding a different bottle of whisky.
About an hour south of here, the Gordie Howe International Bridge crosses the Detroit River. Canada put up $6.4 billion to build it. Then Trump threatened to block the opening and Ottawa agreed to pay the United States an amount equal to half the net crossing revenue for fifteen years. The published terms gave Washington a share from the first fiscal year of operation, without requiring Canada to recover the full cost of building it first.
We’d already paid for the bridge. What Trump brought to the negotiation was the ability to keep it closed. That was enough to get him a cut.
This is where I start to wonder who Carney meant by “Canada” when he put his elbows up. The public had put up the money. The companies moving goods across the border wanted the crossing available. Ottawa took care of that, and the public revenue was what it had to bargain with. Once you start looking at who gets looked after and who gets asked to give something up, the bridge is a pretty good place to start.
The big tech companies already know what they got. Ottawa called off collection before their first payment came due. Arms makers know what Ottawa wants for them, too. The government has set a target to grow their exports by half. Ask what working people were supposed to get out of “elbows up” and suddenly the answer is whatever’s supposed to happen after the companies get what they need. I’m getting tired of being told that’s our turn.
- Ottawa agreed to delay the Gordie Howe bridge opening and later to share fifteen years of net revenue, giving Washington a new claim on a crossing the Canadian public had already paid to build.
- Ottawa carved out and extended exemptions to its countertariffs, including a tariff-free quota for eligible U.S.-assembled vehicles tied to Canadian production, showing how quickly our ability to push back ran up against our dependence on American supply chains.
- Carney held Canada’s steel and aluminum countertariffs at 25 per cent after Trump doubled his to 50, then backed off the July date for a response while Canadian producers were already taking the hit.
- When Trump walked away from trade talks, Ottawa halted collection of the digital services tax before the first payment came due and announced its repeal, and Carney refused to reconsider after talks broke down again, so the tech companies kept what they got even when the bargain had yet to produce a deal.
- Carney removed Canada’s restrictions on ballistic missile defence while Washington was developing Golden Dome, opening the door to building more of our defence around a system the Americans were already designing.
- Ottawa lifted most of its original countertariffs to match the American exemption for goods covered by the trade agreement, easing pressure on U.S. exporters while Canadian steel, aluminum and auto workers were still exposed to sectoral tariffs.
- When Ontario ran an ad using Ronald Reagan’s own words against tariffs, Carney apologized to Trump, as though the thing that needed smoothing over was a province saying out loud what the tariffs were doing.
- In a dispute where Trump had turned the border into a tariff grievance, Carney’s government passed new restrictions on who could make an eligible asylum claim, tightening the rules on people seeking protection here while Washington was demanding a tougher border.
- After the CRTC set a 15-per-cent Canadian-programming requirement for qualifying streamers, Ottawa moved to have it reconsidered and announced $600 million in public support, leaving the public with a funding commitment while what the platforms would eventually owe was still unclear in November.
- Carney asked premiers to return American liquor to the shelves and withdrew the request when the deal fell through, treating one of the few things people could see themselves doing together as something Ottawa could offer up in negotiations.
- Carney voted against sending Bill C-233 to committee, passing up a chance to tighten Canadian control over the U.S. route through which military components can reach countries including Israel.
- On the day the U.S. and Israel attacked Iran, Carney publicly backed U.S. action to prevent Iran getting a nuclear weapon, even though, as he acknowledged days later, neither country had consulted Canada before acting.
- Carney’s government committed roughly $680 million of its 2025 Ukraine military package to buying U.S. equipment and munitions and then committed to years of training and joint weapons production, tying Canada’s response to Russia’s invasion to American suppliers and a military partnership that reaches well beyond any one aid package.
- Carney signed on to NATO’s five-per-cent spending target and extended Canada’s largest overseas deployment, in Latvia, giving the alliance a bigger claim on what Canadians will spend and where Canadian troops will serve.
- The government set a target to grow defence exports by 50 per cent, giving Ottawa an economic reason to keep selling to governments it might otherwise pressure, including Saudi Arabia, Canada’s biggest reported military export customer outside the U.S. in 2025.
- Carney deepened defence cooperation with Saudi Arabia and upgraded the UAE military arrangement alongside an investment pledge, giving Ottawa another reason to stay close to the UAE even as it faced allegations, which it denies, of backing Sudan’s Rapid Support Forces.
- After U.S. forces seized Nicolás Maduro, Carney welcomed the opening for a transition in Venezuela and left the operation itself uncondemned, even though we’d spent much of the previous year explaining why a foreign power had no business deciding Canada’s future.
- Ottawa committed $40 million toward the transition to Haiti’s UN-authorized Gang Suppression Force and backed renewal of its mandate, putting Canadian money behind an international security intervention that gives outside governments a say in how Haiti responds to its own crisis.
Carney did walk away from the August trade talks, and Ottawa did put new countertariffs in place. His government recognized Palestine and sanctioned two Israeli ministers. However, when Carney talks about defending Canada, he keeps treating what big companies need as something the rest of us have to arrange our lives around. The people who do the work are asked to take the risk, pay for the infrastructure and call it patriotism when the terms are settled somewhere else. A Canadian billionaire can get plenty of what he wants out of that arrangement. He can do it under a Canadian flag, too.
In 2024, nearly one in four people in Canada lived in a household that experienced food insecurity. This March, food banks recorded 2.35 million visits in a single month, the highest on record. If you’re a shareholder in one of the big tech companies, you can point to a tax Ottawa took off the books. If you’re trying to pay rent and buy groceries on the same paycheque, what can you point to? When Carney tells us a deal is good for Canada, I want to know who can already see the difference in their bank account and who’s still being told to wait.
So yes, I still want our elbows up. I want a government willing to defend the ability of working people to decide what gets built, who owns it and who gets what it brings in. I want that same freedom for people in countries our allies find inconvenient.
I keep looking for the moment when Carney passes the puck to the rest of us. By now it looks like he’s making out with the people he went into the corner to fight, and everybody’s forgotten there was a puck. Is he willing to take on the people who own damn near everything in this country, or was “elbows up” just what he needed us to say while he made a deal with them?
More to read
Lambton County seeks help assessing risks from legacy oil and gas wells Sacred Heart students and volunteers plant 26 trees at Sarnia school
Bluewater Health Foundation announces $300,000 gift for Sarnia hospital care
Irish Miracle food drive returns Dec. 5
Sarnia Semper: Mike Bradley’s 41 years in public life
Events
Meat Raffles @ Black Gold Brewery
Tue, Nov 17 · 6:00 pm
Black Gold Brewery 395 Fletcher St Petrolia, ON
TV Bingo – Sarnia Seaway Kiwanis
Tue, Nov 17 · 7:00 pm
Cogeco Your TV Channel 6 – HD Channel 700 [OR] Stream with Epico App Sarnia, ON
