Once Upon a Time in a Cinema
Sun, Nov 22 · 2:00 pm
Justice M.A. Cook found the Sarnia councillor had no factual basis for personal allegations against Dawn Flegel and used an unsupported counterclaim as “an instrument of intimidation and financial pressure.”

Sarnia councillor Bill Dennis has been ordered to pay $33,000 in damages to Dawn Flegel, executive director of the Sarnia-Lambton Children’s Aid Society, after the Ontario Superior Court found that a Facebook post it interpreted as accusing her of dishonesty, profiteering and mental instability was defamatory.
Justice M.A. Cook granted summary judgment to Flegel in a decision released June 16, finding there was no genuine issue requiring a trial. The court also dismissed Dennis’s $375,000 counterclaim after finding he presented no evidence to support it, asked Flegel no questions about it during discovery and did not address it in his written argument.
Cook described the counterclaim as “an instrument of intimidation and financial pressure” that had been maintained with an “unjustifiable intention to injure” Flegel.
The full judgment in *Flegel v. Dennis, 2026 ONSC 3532* is available here.
The dispute began in May 2024 over an SLCAS recruitment advertisement that said the agency was looking for applicants identifying as Indigenous, Black, racialized, 2SLGBTQ+ or bilingual French-speaking.
SLCAS said the recruitment approach reflected the overrepresentation of Indigenous, Black and 2SLGBTQ+ families in the child-welfare system, the effects of systemic racism and colonization, the importance of providing services in languages families understand and the need for greater representation in organizational decision-making.
The posting did not explicitly state that applicants outside the listed groups were barred. Its closing language also welcomed applications from racialized groups, First Nations, Inuit or Métis people, people with disabilities and people of any sexual orientation, gender identity or gender expression.
Dennis criticized the advertisement in a May 15 Facebook post, characterizing its identity-focused recruitment language as “discrimination.” He said that, if elected mayor, he would not provide municipal funding to organizations he believed practised discriminatory hiring and promised to “restore common sense and kick woke out of City Hall.”
Flegel, who has led SLCAS since 2012, later authored a letter to the editor in The Sarnia Journal that was co-signed by the Social Services Network of Sarnia-Lambton, a coalition of approximately 30 health and social-service organizations.
The letter did not identify Dennis by name. It said the assertion by a city councillor that actively seeking qualified applicants from diverse backgrounds constituted discrimination was “not only misguided” but “dangerously undermines” the work of SLCAS.
At approximately 2:39 p.m. on May 23, the Journal published a separate news article reporting that Flegel had filed complaints against Dennis with Sarnia’s integrity commissioner and the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario.
About an hour later, at 3:42 p.m., Dennis published the Facebook post that became the subject of the lawsuit.
“The director of the SLCAS is a Grifter who actually purchased a luxury mansion on the St. Clair Parkway in Corunna,” Dennis wrote. “Clearly lots of money to be made in the race hustling / victim business. Just another far left wacko elitist.”
The post also referred to Flegel and others as “bat shit crazy lunatics that try to destroy you if you don’t agree with them.” The Journal article identifying Flegel appeared directly below Dennis’s comments.
Dennis used the public Facebook page for both personal and political purposes and had approximately 8,700 followers at the time. By May 31, the post had received 641 public engagements, 339 comments and 59 shares.
The judgment said many comments were derogatory toward Flegel. Commenters described her as an “elitist pos” and “a goof,” said she “shouldn’t have kids,” and argued that she should be investigated for being racist and ignorant.
Dennis liked and replied to several of the comments. In one response, he wrote that Flegel “makes a lot of money and messes up alot of families and children.” Cook found that Dennis selectively deleted comments critical of himself while preserving derogatory comments about Flegel.
The post also disclosed that Flegel had previously purchased a home on St. Clair Parkway. Although she no longer lived there, her former husband and child continued to occupy the property.
Flegel contacted the Ontario Provincial Police after seeing the post, and police helped her develop a safety plan for herself and her family. Her unchallenged evidence was that she experienced increased anxiety, changed her routines, had uncomfortable encounters with members of the public and spent time at work managing harassment directed at SLCAS.
She suffered no loss of employment, salary, business opportunity or formal reprimand. Cook considered those factors, together with the retaliatory context of the dispute, when determining the amount of general damages.
Dennis admitted during examination for discovery that he had no factual basis for allegations that Flegel was a swindler, personally profited from “race hustling” or was mentally unstable. He also indicated that he was not relying on truth as a defence to the personal meaning of those statements.
Dennis argued that he intended only to call Flegel a hypocrite. Cook found that his personal intention was not the legal test. The issue was how an ordinary, fair-minded reader would understand the words in their full context.
The judge found that the defamatory “sting” of the post was that Flegel was mentally unstable and had misused her SLCAS position to exploit race and identity issues for personal financial gain.
“The words make specific imputations of dishonesty, profiteering, and unfitness against a specific individual,” Cook wrote.
The court said those allegations struck directly at the honesty, integrity and professional judgment required of the chief executive of a publicly funded child-welfare agency serving Sarnia-Lambton, including three local First Nations communities.
Dennis also admitted that he was not carrying out his responsibilities as a councillor when he published the post. He said he acted out of personal frustration and was “punching back” at Flegel over her letter.
Cook nevertheless found that the broader context mattered when determining damages. The judge described Flegel’s letter and her decision to draw public attention to the integrity commissioner and human-rights complaints as “highly provocative.”
Provocation is not a defence to defamation, but Cook treated the escalating and retaliatory context as a factor moderating the general-damages award. The court distinguished between Dennis’s original criticism of the SLCAS recruitment policy and the later allegations directed at Flegel personally, finding the May 23 post went “beyond rhetorical excess in the heat of political debate.”
Once Flegel established that the post was defamatory, the burden shifted to Dennis to establish a valid defence.
His truth defence failed because he produced no evidence that the personal allegations were substantially true. Dennis attempted to rely on evidence alleging that Flegel had influenced SLCAS board members to hire her then-husband in 2013, but Cook found that even accepting that evidence would not establish the truth of the May 23 statements.
The fair-comment defence failed because the allegations were presented as factual claims rather than recognizable opinions based on established facts. The responsible-communication defence failed because Dennis provided no evidence that he had taken steps to verify the personal allegations before publishing them.
Qualified privilege was also unavailable. Dennis admitted he was acting from personal frustration rather than performing his councillor duties, and he published the statements openly on Facebook, where they could be shared without restriction.
The court rejected his Charter argument because Charter protections generally apply to state action, not private disputes, and Dennis had not established that Flegel was acting as a state actor. Cook found that any support or funding SLCAS may have provided for her lawsuit did not transform her personal defamation action into government action.
Municipal Act immunity did not apply because Dennis was not performing, or attempting to perform, a municipal duty when he published the post. His Human Rights Code reprisal argument also failed because he had not commenced or participated in a protected human-rights proceeding at the relevant time.
Dennis responded to Flegel’s lawsuit with a counterclaim alleging Charter violations, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office and reprisal under the Human Rights Code. He also sought a declaration that Flegel was a vexatious litigant.
The counterclaim sought $375,000, although Dennis waived any recovery above $200,000 to keep the case within Ontario’s simplified civil procedure.
Cook found that Dennis presented no evidence supporting any of those allegations. He did not ask Flegel a single question about the counterclaim during discovery and did not address its merits in his written argument on the summary-judgment motion. His position was that dismissing it without a trial would be premature.
The judge rejected that argument, noting that parties responding to a summary-judgment motion are expected to present their strongest available evidence.
“Mr. Dennis’ failure to lead evidence does not render the motion for summary judgment premature; it makes the counterclaim ripe for summary dismissal,” Cook wrote.
The court awarded Flegel $25,000 in general damages, considering her professional position, the seriousness of the allegations, the reach and replication of Dennis’s post, her safety concerns and the resulting anxiety and harassment.
Another $8,000 was awarded in aggravated damages based on two aspects of Dennis’s conduct.
First, Cook found that disclosing Flegel’s former residential location alongside allegations of corruption and dishonesty exposed her former husband and child to potential harassment and harm at their home.
Second, the court found that Dennis maintained a counterclaim with no evidentiary foundation.
“A claim initiated with no evidentiary foundation and abandoned in all but formal assertion at the hearing is not bona fide litigation,” Cook wrote. “It is an instrument of intimidation and financial pressure.”
Cook said the counterclaim aggravated the harm to Flegel’s dignity, security and peace of mind. The award also registered the court’s denunciation of “the use of the litigation process as an instrument of intimidation.”
Dennis must also pay pre- and post-judgment interest. Flegel is presumptively entitled to recover legal costs, although the amount was not fixed in the judgment. The parties were encouraged to reach an agreement; otherwise, Flegel may submit her costs claim by July 7 and Dennis may respond by July 14.
The court declined to award punitive damages, finding that the combined $33,000 compensatory award was sufficient to denounce the conduct and deter similar behaviour.
Cook also considered the earlier integrity commissioner proceeding, which found that Dennis’s post violated Sarnia council’s Code of Conduct and recommended a two-day suspension of his remuneration. The judge concluded that a further punitive award was unnecessary.
The court declined to issue a permanent injunction against future defamatory statements. Dennis removed the post in June 2024 after receiving a formal libel notice, and there was no evidence the defamation was continuing.
Although Dennis admitted he would not have removed the post without the notice, Cook found little risk that he would continue to defame Flegel and concluded that damages were an adequate remedy. The balance of Flegel’s requested relief, including a court-ordered public apology and retraction, was dismissed.
Dennis said in an email to Sarnia News Today after the decision that he was strongly considering an appeal. He continued to defend his criticism of the SLCAS recruitment advertisement and said hiring should be based on merit.
The judgment did not determine whether the advertisement’s recruitment language was discriminatory or otherwise unlawful. It addressed Dennis’s later Facebook post and found that his comments moved beyond criticism of SLCAS policy into unsupported personal allegations about Flegel.
In a statement provided to Sarnia News Today, Flegel’s lawyer, Jacob Damstra, said the ruling had vindicated her reputation and confirmed that Dennis’s statements had gone beyond political debate.
Damstra said the damages addressed the harm to Flegel’s reputation, dignity and security, as well as Dennis’s use of the litigation process as an instrument of intimidation.

Sarnia councillors propose deputy mayor, financial reviews and searchable voting records
New Sarnia council faces projected $2.3-million year-end deficit

Sun, Nov 22 · 2:00 pm
Mon, Nov 23 · 7:00 pm
St Andrew’s Presbyterian Church 261 Christina St N Sarnia, ON