‘Tracking and monitoring’: Davis filing reveals allegation involving media personnel and external law-enforcement officer
Davis says Police Board chair Kelly Ash wrote to him June 7 that it was alleged he had participated in or directed the tracking and monitoring of “media personnel and an external law enforcement officer.” The filing does not identify those people, explain the alleged methods or disclose supporting evidence, and Davis says all allegations against him are without merit.

A court filing by suspended Sarnia police chief Derek Davis has made public an allegation that he participated in or directed the tracking and monitoring of media personnel and an external law-enforcement officer.
The allegation appears in Davis’s July 22 Notice to Arbitrate, now filed as an exhibit in his Ontario Superior Court application against the Sarnia Police Service Board, under the heading “Alleged Unauthorized Surveillance.”
Davis’s filing says Police Board chair Kelly Ash wrote to him June 7 and advised: “it is alleged that you participated in or directed the tracking and monitoring of media personnel and an external law enforcement officer”
Immediately after the quotation attributed to Ash, Davis’s lawyers add the words “without any cause or authority.”
The quotation attributed to Ash ends after “external law enforcement officer.” The words “without any cause or authority” appear outside those quotation marks, meaning the application record does not establish that Ash herself used that language.
The filing contains an allegation, not a finding. It does not establish that any tracking or monitoring occurred, identify the media personnel or officer, explain what “tracking and monitoring” meant or disclose the evidence behind the allegation.
Davis denies the allegations against him.
Later in the same Notice to Arbitrate, he states: “All of the allegations are without merit.”
Davis’s filing says that as of July 22, the Board had not provided him with the substance of the alleged unauthorized surveillance and that he did not know the status of whatever investigations may have been initiated.
It also says Ash’s June 7 email did not identify the source of the allegation, although Davis’s lawyers assert that “in fact, it originated with the Association.”
That is Davis’s allegation. The portion of Ash’s message quoted in the filing does not identify the Sarnia Police Association as the source.
According to Davis’s filing, Ash told him May 5 that “some members raised concerns about you engaged in workplace harassment [sic]” following an April 30 meeting between the Police Board and Police Association members. Lawyer Nathaniel Marshall was retained to investigate.
On May 18, Davis says Ash advised him of additional allegations involving his secondary employment, including a complaint that he was using Sarnia Police Service resources to further Norigen Consulting.
Davis’s filing says Ash then advised him that, “as a result of these allegations,” he was suspended from performing his duties as chief until further notice.
The Board publicly announced Davis’s suspension with pay on May 19, saying it had initiated a formal, independent workplace-harassment investigation and describing the suspension as a “standard administrative procedure.” The Board stressed that it “does not imply any determination of wrongdoing.”
According to Davis’s filing, the monitoring allegation was not put to him until June 7.
He was therefore already suspended when it arose. The available record does not support saying Davis was suspended because of the allegation involving media personnel and an external law-enforcement officer.
Separately, public Police Board records document a recurring SPS practice of collecting and discussing published media coverage during Davis’s tenure.
By the spring of 2026, “Media Scan” had become a recurring Police Board agenda item. At the April 23 meeting, Davis described it as a relatively new component of Board reporting prepared through corporate communications to provide an overview of SPS coverage and an opportunity to clarify issues raised in the news.
The accompanying April 23 Media Scan catalogued stories by outlet, including Sarnia Journal reporting. It said SPS sometimes encountered false or misleading information and that among some local individuals and media sources, “misinformation and disinformation are prominent.” The report said SPS would address those individuals or outlets case by case.
The May 21 Police Board agenda package contained another Media Scan bearing Davis’s name and dated May 21.
In discussing an April 28 police media conference, the report identified journalists from Blackburn News, YourTV, CBC Windsor, CTV London, The Sarnia Observer and The Petrolia Independent, then separately stated: “An individual from a local website, The Sarnia Journal, was barred from the final media conference because of their past behaviour, and the organization’s desire to insulate the family from any inappropriate behaviour.”
The exclusion had occurred on April 28 and was recorded by Colquhoun.
In a video recorded at the entrance to the April 28 media conference, Journal contributor Nathan Colquhoun asks an SPS officer whether he is allowed inside.
The officer refuses. When Colquhoun asks why, the officer tells him: “specifically with you, he has an issue with you. So that is his request.”
Colquhoun then asks whether that request will be enforced and whether the officer could instead allow him inside and have Davis ask him to leave directly.
The officer replies: “No.”
Later in the exchange, the officer tells Colquhoun: “I can’t let you in.”
The video does not record Davis personally giving an instruction. It does record an SPS officer telling Colquhoun that his exclusion was specifically Davis’s request.
The May Media Scan subsequently recorded the exclusion and gave SPS’s stated reason for it.
Later in that same report, under “Social Media,” Colquhoun was included alongside local Facebook groups, Reddit, Councillor Bill Dennis and Brandon McCaskill and described as a “former city councillor and website owner/contributor.” The report then listed a series of Journal articles.
The Journal challenged its classification directly with the Police Board on June 1.
Ash responded the following day: “We acknowledge that the classification of The Sarnia Journal in the May 21, 2026 Media Scan report was not accurate.”
She said future Board materials would use “more appropriate and accurate categorizations.”
Ash, writing as Board chair, acknowledged that the Journal had been inaccurately classified in the Media Scan.
The April 28 exclusion establishes that SPS denied Colquhoun access to one media conference and that the officer enforcing the exclusion attributed the decision specifically to Davis.
Neither fact establishes that Colquhoun, the Journal or anyone associated with it was among the unidentified “media personnel” in Davis’s later monitoring allegation.
Restricting access to a media conference and reviewing published journalism are also not the same thing as tracking or monitoring journalists themselves.
The records establish that published media coverage was regularly compiled for the Police Board, that Journal reporting was included and that SPS excluded Colquhoun from one media conference. The court filing does not say whether any of those events had any relationship to the later monitoring allegation.
The filing leaves the central details of that allegation unexplained.
It does not identify the media personnel. It does not identify the “external law enforcement officer”, their employer, rank or jurisdiction. And it identifies no method, technology, database, physical surveillance or other technique allegedly used.
Davis’s Notice says that, in connection with the June 7 allegation, Ash “again advised that the Board was filing a complaint with LECA.”
That too is Davis’s account.
The 61-page application record reviewed by the Journal does not contain a separately exhibited copy of that LECA referral or an acknowledgment from LECA concerning the allegation.
Ash’s complete June 7 email is also not separately exhibited.
The application record’s index lists Davis’s employment agreement and correspondence dated May 28, June 5, July 15, July 22, July 23, July 24 and July 29, along with the July 22 Notice to Arbitrate. A June 7 email from Ash is not separately listed.
What is public through the court filing is therefore Davis’s lawyers’ quotation and description of that correspondence, rather than the complete original email and its surrounding context.
The record establishes something narrower than whether surveillance actually occurred.
Davis says that on June 7, while already suspended, Ash put to him an allegation that he had participated in or directed the tracking and monitoring of media personnel and an external law-enforcement officer. Davis denies the allegations and says he was not provided their substance.
Separately, SPS had a documented practice of compiling and discussing published media coverage, including reporting by The Sarnia Journal, and Colquhoun had been excluded from an SPS media conference at what an officer told him was Davis’s request.
The public record does not establish any connection between those events and the monitoring allegation.
The allegation is now public. The evidence behind it is not.
About this reporting: This story is based principally on Derek Davis’s July 22 Notice to Arbitrate, filed as an exhibit in his Ontario Superior Court application against the Sarnia Police Service Board, together with Police Board agenda packages, recordings of public Board meetings, contemporaneous video of the April 28 media-conference exclusion and correspondence between The Sarnia Journal and Board chair Kelly Ash. The Notice contains allegations and legal positions advanced by Davis that have not been adjudicated. The complete June 7 email described in the Notice is not included as a separate exhibit in the 61-page application record. The Journal has therefore reported the allegation as Davis’s account and has not identified any person or organization as an alleged subject of monitoring where the record itself does not do so.
About the documents: Court documents linked in this story are publication copies prepared by The Sarnia Journal. Redactions are limited to signatures, direct contact information and private family or beneficiary information. No substantive filing content has been removed or altered.
Disclosure: Davis previously sued Nathan Colquhoun, The Sarnia Journal and Sarnia Media Group Inc. Nothing in the application record identifies Colquhoun, the Journal or anyone associated with the publication as one of the unidentified “media personnel” referred to in the tracking-and-monitoring allegation.
More to read
Sarnia Legion resignations follow trusteeship linked to executive standoff
Former Salvation Army thrift store plans free merchandise giveaway Saturday
County plans Nov. 9 opening celebration for Kathleen Avenue housing
Sarnia election results 2026: Mayor, council and trustees
Indwell wins George Street appeal after years of resistance to supportive housing
Events
cineSARNIA presents The President’s Cake
Sun, Nov 8 · 2:00 pm
Sarnia Public Library Theatre 124 Christina St. S Sarnia, ON

